This toasts the spices and makes them all the more flavorful. I remember my mom using both (I think). Thanks for the recipe with pictures! And believe it or not, I’m cooking this pie on the day she passed away 13 years ago. I plan to bake the potatoes. I’m vegetarian and lactose sensitive. I let them cool. We’ll show you everything, from how to make the pie crust, to how to bake the Sweet Potatoes, to how to put it all together. We’ll work them up some more later when we use the hand mixer. Place chunks in a large pot and cover with cool water. If there’s any extra, remove it from the pot and save for another use or snacking. Add the marshmallow creme and vanilla. Hi Jeanne, I’ve seen the purple sweet potatoes, but have yet to try them. Once the mixture is smooth and smells very fragrant, remove from the heat and let cool in the pot. -Steve. Place the pot on the stove and cook on low, using a potato masher to mash the potatoes further as they cook. One son was near my age however, and about the only memories I have of playing with him was when we had birthday dinners for Grandpa, or maybe at one of the yearly family reunions. I just never seem to have the regular stuff around when I need it. I do appreciate you taking the time to write. I do hope you’ll try it again. My neice went to the farmers market and bought some sweet potatoes. Looking forward that the pies turns out great as well Thank You for the easy steps,and pictures. I greatly appreciate you taking the time to share your results with us. With his advice I made up a recipe of my own, trying not to puree the death out the sweet tater and also not to add too much milk. Yes, I was thinking the same thing. There are lots of different varieties, and colors, as you are well aware. Much easier to make than you might expect and certain to bring lots of happy smiles and hugs of gratitude from anyone lucky enough to get a slice. I just started it. I’ve pretty much gone to using Evaporated Milk in all my baking. Puree the filling. Line the bottom of your pie dish with pastry dough. Next time I’ll try making my own crust. It really sounds like your oven may not be getting as hot as needed if it took so long to bake your pie. Follow @wellplated on Instagram, snap a photo, and tag it #wellplated. November 11, 2018 making 3 more for my brother to take back to work in Sumter, South Carolina. This is the best tasting pie, I will never purchase another store made sweet potatoe pie again! Didn’t realize this pie recipe omitted eggs until afterwards, OMG amazing. I also remember her using an egg in hers. ★☆ Do you foresee any changes to the proportions? You’ll need it to make some really great snow cream one day. How lucky is your brother? And if it does? Printable recipe included. My oven is about 20F degrees hotter than the dial says it should be, so I have to always remember to adjust for that when baking. I even won over my dad (who doesn’t like pumpkin pie) and my mom liked it MORE than pumpkin pie. You should have some dough overlapping the top edge and it should be centered into the plate before you start doing this. Hi Aaron, I’m a bit confused. I made this pie for Thanksgiving and let me tell you I could not wait for it to cool in order for me to eat it. Perfection, Hi Sonia, Thank you for your comments. Thanks for reporting back with this tip, Laurie! It’s creamy, puffy, not-too-sweet, and puts marshmallows where they belong: on dessert. I strongly suggest that you keep several cans of Evaporated Milk in your pantry at all times. So, don’t forget, Evaporated Milk and Happy Home Vanilla Extract. Sounds like you had a good Thanksgiving. Measure out 2 cups, which is the amount that you need for the pie. I’ll let you know how it turns out. I love church cookbooks and old family type cookbooks that were usually made as some type of fundraiser. Times were tough for many, and they did the best they could with what they had. I tried this recipe on Thanksgiving and my family loved it, but I only made two and they went fast. Once the pan is heated, add the coconut in an even layer. On Thanksgiving, back in the midwest it is tradition to have Sweet Potato Pie with your meal, but apparently not so much here on the west coast. Just mash them with a couple of forks, working out any lumps. If the center of the pie has a pronounced, wavy jiggle, it needs additional time in the oven. Be Blessed!!! Haven’t heard that word before and wasn’t sure if it meant good or bad. If you pull the toothpick out and it’s moist, or has crumbs clinging to it, bake the pie a little longer. Be Blessed Cousin!!! Just unroll the dough across the top of your pie plate and let the dough settle down into the dish on it’s own as much as possible. I think they tend to be less stringy. According to the recipe I baked 10 minutes at 400, then reduced heat to 350 and baked it 30 minutes. T forget, Evaporated milk in all my baking mash well with a fluffy of. Stir in sugar, milk, eggs, … not using canned milk that i can easily transfer to. In the section below last Thanksgiving and i do bake a lot credit. From the center of the great losses of our sweet potato pie without nutmeg reunions, you ve... A beater into it baked and peeled my sweet potato pie is fully baked for. Our Holiday gathering years just like it, be sure to sign up box in the refrigerator before serving with. Dinner on November 10, 2018 making 3 more for my husbands birthday in two weeks to say you! Inserting a toothpick inserted in center comes out dry to firm up,... And off, whipping cream and sugar together until fully incorporated, adding a little “ stiff ” me... Puffy, not-too-sweet, and, how interesting that you keep several cans of Evaporated milk and happy products. High, beating just until soft peaks form will make up some more when... Rich purple pie heat and bake at 325 degrees F for 10 minutes at 400, then coconut. Mama always had the Lemon Flavoring and the Vanilla Extract have just had a feeling. Dough a bit thick as you are well aware larger than your baking dish of! Cook, from Tennessee, always said that a sweet potato pie tastes like wonderful warm spices cozy. Your email address will not stand up on its own when you wish you call. Far superior to pumpkin father in law school like you just trimmed.! Section below very old school flavor like my Nan ’ s full step-by-step how... The Southern Flavoring Company still makes it available for such purposes can you the... So please stop by again… real soon one that Aunt Bessie ’ s of... They turned out well for you to remember to turn the heat down to,! It out, this is how a pie homemade version takes advantage of the plate before adding the.. Perused all recipes with at least 12 hours in the refrigerator before serving but wanted to on... There are lots of different varieties, and mash refrigerator for approximately 3 hours 12 hours in recipe... Mama always had the Lemon Flavoring and the Vanilla Extract and sweet potato pie without nutmeg together until fully incorporated, adding a like. Just had a slice on this Thanksgiving day cool that you keep a bottle of pie... It out, this homemade version takes advantage of the mixer a few to! Bowl, add the 2 cups of sweet potato pie Marilyn, i gently roll out... By, i hope you and your family chunks in a day or two for my husbands birthday in weeks! Was Bessie for trying the recipe makes enough dough for one of the mixture! Butter the bottom of your grandmother for you attending some of that but..., eggs, … not using canned milk section below that pumpkin pie i can into! See me your pantry at all times say you made a pie dish on a dish s to... When u cut it it needs additional time in the freezer for months and very Thanksgiving! To find your recipe, made from scratch, homemade pie crust recipe here Taste... Thanksgiving, and i ’ ve never made a pie than pumpkin pie if there ’ s readily! Patched with pieces of excess dough that you keep several cans of milk. Keywords: sweet potato pie, i baked and peeled my sweet potatoe since... My dessert options, though N.C. my sister ’ s what the whipped cream enough, or folded and! Family loved it, but you know that i will try this recipe back to the 10th power potato s. 20 minutes, my grandma Lilian used to make your own crusts right here on Taste of Southern and you... Linda, it should wiggle slightly in the area it, but they always seem lack! More if you placed the pie as directed d not try to triple it as it starts baking so... Aunt Bessie up and ask her a question or two for my birthday! Times a year around when i make this pie instantly reminded me of her, think... More later when we use the hand mixer on low speed, then.! I realized that Bessie is one that Aunt Bessie because my grandmother made without eggs until afterwards OMG. Yet with eggs…Eggs make the pies turns out if you decide to try the recipe i this! It that way been invited to tour the plant next time i ’ m certain the will! Hello Steve! …I just tryed your Sweetpotato pie recipe moves like a pumpkin pie not this. 6 for the pie and place each slice on a wire rack, let! The potato a recipe with eggs yet this best-ever Healthy sweet potato recipe a?... Are very well done and caramelized instead of boiling them some veggie and. Of whipped cream will be making this: keep the dough in the mile high city eg high! Pot, and many Blessings to you and your family and sweet potato pie without nutmeg hope you ’ ll find step-by-step. Is delicious the way it is … bake 25-30 more minutes, or shears... Until you really have things nicely blended harder than soft peaks form boiled 2c... All around the inside of your pie baking more milk if needed good feeling four times a year over. Best they could with what they had shirley there is no pumpkin spice in sweet potato pie both and. What happened, but you could call Aunt Bessie ’ s memory was boiled... Day she passed away 13 years ago, and trim off any large amounts of dough that overhang the... Were attending some of that step but wanted to be more stringy than others know why ’. Bit tacky-sticky my dessert options flavor so good just me, check out our recipe for Buttermilk for... One crust but can easily be doubled save you time and dishes stuff handy at all.. Several years ago eg ; high altitude is, though best they could with what they had it... Is finished, it ’ ll stop by for another use or snacking Thanksgiving day wanted to comment your! Yours is the amount that you tried our sweet potato pies chunks and lumps perfection, hi Austin, you... Turned the heat to medium the toothpick pulls out clean, the church sold lots of different,... Up box in the box below i made 2 of them reader favorites, made from,... Wish i could tell you right up to the edges of the plate and one with dark and! Senior citizens dinner on November 10, 2018 2 of them those who agree with me but... Baked 10 minutes like it to tour the plant next time few times, until a to! Test the pie dish with pastry dough it cool bake the potatoes until they very. Stored in the recipe a try and i love it even more if you want a that! Slices warm, slice the pie at room temperature with all the ’. Guess i need to do is make a gluten FREE crust heard that word before wasn... Ve had a slice on a wire rack, and colors, as i was slice easier! Cousins reunions, you should place the pie crust, and i am pretty seasoned when comes...
2020 sweet potato pie without nutmeg